In an earlier post, I shared a link to Craig Duff’s piece, “5 Things Cities Can Learn From Burning Man.”
One reader wanted to know more about the fourth lesson, when Larry Harvey talks about “shame [being] more efficacious than virtue.” Rather than speculating, I emailed Craig Duff to ask him to elaborate on that point. Duff emailed back to explain that Harvey was referring to how Burners practice “Leave No Trace,” in which they pack out their own trash. In the past, Burning Man organizers would publish a “list of shame” identifying theme camps by name that had left behind debris. Fellow Burners would then chastise those camps. As many active Burners know, reputation matters. The “stick” of (potential) public humiliation is enough to compel some people to comply.
On the other hand, what’s even more compelling is Burning Man’s innovative use of “carrots.” That is, people think of creative ways to make otherwise dreary activities – like recycling or picking up trash – fun and even enjoyable. In my book, I talk about the origins and intent of Recycle Camp, which collects and crushes aluminum cans. Co-founder Simon Hagger wanted to make the activity of recycling fun for people, so he built a special pedal-powered contraption to crush cans, and he also gave mallets for people to hand-crush cans. He said that some people seemed to imagine their least favorite person, such as their boss, as the target while whacking the cans. (Managers, take note: maybe you can kill two birds with one stone: sublimate your underlings’ unhappy feelings into recycling.)
Recycle Camp still continues that tradition today. Check out this photo of Recycle Camp from this past event, 2009:
Volunteers bicycle around the city to collect cans, and people also bring their cans to Recycle Camp. The fellow at the left is transferring collected cans into a container, which he will then dump onto the sorting table. At the sorting table, people push recyclable cans towards the middle, where a person (in this photo, the guy wearing the white vest) pedals two large wheels that crush the cans for recycling.
So there you have it: Burning Man’s version of the carrot and the stick. To close, Duff’s take-away point for cities is to “foster…virtue, even if you have to shame people into it.”
wow – thanks for going the extra mile and going to the source! ^_^
you remind me how some of my best memories are from clean up! the energy is so pure. to think about raising the bar the next time i participate in cleanup and think of creative games to make it fun for everybody sounds like a cool challenge!
You stated that terrifically.
viagra search sites find free why do men want viagra
buy viagra
edinburgh viagra chances charles linskaill – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Fine stuff. Kudos.
can you take viagra and adderall buy viagra and overseas
buy viagra
viagra how fast – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thank you. I like it.
usa online pharmacies that sell viagra prices of viagra
buy viagra online
everyday viagra dosage – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Amazing stuff, Cheers.
generic viagra sales buy viagra with cashiers check
viagra pills
2cialis compare levitra viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Seriously tons of superb information!
womens issues viagra affects of viagra
viagra for sale uk
viagra head office photo – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Seriously a lot of fantastic info.
viagra and anger side effects how long are viagra good for
generic viagra online
viagra how soon before sex – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Truly lots of great knowledge.
viagra add url viagra with sex
viagra online
viagra and cialis use – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Excellent info. Thanks a lot.
cheap dream pharmaceutical viagra viagra questions
viagra for women
viagra genetic indian pharmacy – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Superb info, Thanks!
viagra for ladies moon flowers viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
is viagra over the table – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Very good info. Thanks a lot!
viagra funny lisinopril viagra
viagra for sale uk
submit a site viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Info effectively utilized..
clonidine hcl viagra viagra sizes
viagra without a doctor prescription
buy cheap deal online viagra viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You mentioned that perfectly!
over the counter viagra walgreens viagra for canadians
generic viagra online
stimula viagra levitra – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Wow all kinds of great facts.
find viagra free online pages edinburgh viagra shelf life
viagra pills
viagra teen birth – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thanks! Helpful stuff!
viagra versus cialis espa ol vision loss and viagra
viagra 100mg
www viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Many thanks, A good amount of advice.
buy sublingual viagra online viagra and antidepressents and women
viagra without a doctors prescription
viagra premature – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Many thanks, Great stuff!
average cost of viagra in stores viagra uk
viagra for sale uk
free viagra prescription – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You expressed that very well.
tesco stores viagra comparison viagra cialis levitra
viagra without a doctor prescription
bisoprolol hydrochlorothiazide viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Cheers, Numerous advice.
viagra dangers viagra testosterone
viagra generic
viagra sales uk – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Excellent posts. Regards.
cheapest mail order viagra viagra free sites find search pages
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra springwood – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thank you! Terrific stuff.
fre viagra reliability of generic viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra on-linw into singapore – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thanks a lot! Quite a lot of content.
cialis compared to viagra search viagra viagra find edinburgh free
generic viagra 100mg
viagra delivery tou days – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Wow a good deal of wonderful facts.
viagra online canda erection after orgasm viagra
generic viagra 100mg
viagra find edinburgh charles pages – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Whoa plenty of helpful facts!
caverta generic viagra generic viagra pillshoprxcom female viagra virginia
generic viagra online
cocks on viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You actually stated that well.
viagra side efects viagra best price on net
viagra without a doctor prescription
review online viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
viagra best results pharmacy viagra paxil
viagra 100mg
negative effects viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
With thanks. Loads of data.
viagra sales on line side-effects viagra
generic viagra
cialis cialis genuinerx net viagra viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Nicely put, Thank you.
viagra patent expire date football viagra
viagra online
get viagra at an online pharmacy – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You definitely made the point.
doctor millington viagra viagra slicer
generic viagra
discount generic viagra soft tabs – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You revealed this perfectly.
use viagra while drunk viagra cyallis
buy viagra online
viagra patent expiration date – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
This is nicely expressed. .
viagra health concerns viagra stroke
viagra for women
what is a viagra overdose – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You said it adequately.!
cough cialas viagra buy viagra in australia
buy viagra
medicare and viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
This is nicely put! .
proven competitor to viagra cialis levitra cost cialis viagra
generic viagra 100mg
viagra anorgasmia – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thanks a lot, Lots of content!
pfizer viagra pharmacy online sellers of cialis and viagra
generic viagra 100mg
viagra samples shopping – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
This is nicely put! .
buy viagra in malaysia caverta generic viagra caverta caverta pillshoprxcom
cheap viagra
other medication the same as viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Great facts. Thanks a lot.
lakshmi snow white viagra girl mail order viagra prescriptions
viagra 100mg
pharmacy viagra cheap – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Regards! I value it.
what if viagra foes not work water melon viagra
viagra for sale uk
viagra young healthy – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You expressed this effectively!
what women say about viagra viagra sale online a href
generic viagra online
strengths and weaknesses of viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thanks. Good information.
edinburgh viagra find order search viagra in the water
viagra without a doctors prescription
viagra for women germany – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You said it nicely..
womans backlash to viagra viagra frequency of priapism
buy viagra
watermelon viagra affect – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
This is nicely said. !
diabectics viagra viagra spike
generic viagra
canada drugs viagra without prescription – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You explained that fantastically!
average cost of viagra in stores ensure viagra
viagra online
viagra suppliers uk – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You revealed this wonderfully.
viagra equivilent wedding viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
isentress viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Lovely information, Thank you!
generic viagra since there viagra siesta
cheap viagra
viagra mechanism of action – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Lovely info. With thanks.
age of men who take viagra organic viagra alternative
viagra pills
can viagra pills be split – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Whoa lots of terrific material!
viagra to buy cheap viagra soft how to take
buy viagra online
indiana online viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Info clearly regarded..
viagra effect on women viagra little blue pill
viagra pills
viagra in mexico for sale – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Reliable info. Cheers!
pharmaceutical viagra cialis levitra pens viagra best price on net scam
viagra without a doctor prescription
is viagra better – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You made your position quite effectively.!
toprol-xl and viagra is it dangerous recommended dosage for viagra
buy viagra
search viagra viagra edinburgh – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thanks a lot, I appreciate it.
1 generic viagra viagra in your retum work
cheap viagra
viagra for recreational use younger men – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Wow quite a lot of fantastic material.
stories of viagra viagra in the waters karaoke
cheap viagra
waiting period for viagra before sex – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Nicely put. Kudos!
viagra pulmonary heart viagra and facial numbness
buy generic viagra
viagra description – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thank you! Terrific information.
viagra fir women consumer report best natural viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
generic viagra a – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Seriously tons of excellent tips.
gay sleep viagra viagra levitra sexual health
generic viagra 100mg
online prescription viagra phentermine meridia adi – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Fantastic advice. Many thanks.
viagra pharmacies cialis mixing viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
shelf life of viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Many thanks! Helpful information!
side effects of snorting viagra price of viagra 100mg tablet
generic viagra 100mg
viagra dosing – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thanks a lot, Ample knowledge!
best instructions for taking generic viagra english viagra
generic viagra 100mg
viagra best – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Seriously many of amazing info!
african viagra everyday viagra doseage
viagra without a doctor prescription
combine levitra viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You revealed that well!
compare levitra and viagra viagra before surgery
viagra generic
viagra safe for trying to conceive – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
You reported it adequately!
penis pump or viagra oakville cro viagra
generic viagra online
viagra fix a flat – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Wow lots of wonderful knowledge.
lung diseases treated with viagra viagra erythromycin dosage
viagra online
marketing viagra vs cialis – https://genericviagramsl.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
Thanks, Very good stuff!
clarisa nora doctorovich viagra genuine viagra box
viagra 100mg
cialis comparison levitra viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette
This is nicely said. !
viagra litigation viagra prices 50mg and 100mg
viagra 100mg
deleuze on viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com
Davidgew
TerenceFoots
VictorFette